Today I read two articles concerning the Jordan Davis murder trial, SYG and self-defense laws. I’ve included the links below.
There is no white boogeyman – Yolanda Young
It’s not about ‘stand your ground’, it’s about race – Mark O’Mara
I see a lot of what Mark O’Mara is saying, particularly his assumption that the whole problem with the self-defense laws is the ‘no duty to retreat” clause as well as the definition of “reasonable fear”. But there’s more.
“The underlying concern with the statute is that those who are aware of it may be emboldened by its protection and place themselves in, or remain in, a circumstance that increases the likelihood of using force.” – Mark O’Mara
Mr. O’Mara’s correct that reasonable fear can become entirely unreasonable when the fear is stemming from a confrontation with a black male. And if his quote above doesn’t, in fact, describe what possibly was going through Zimmerman’s mind that evening last year-that self-defense or SYG laws gave him the right to confront the unarmed teen, consequences be damned-then I don’t know what does. I only wonder where all of these good, objective thoughts were during the Zimmerman trial. You have to love defense attorneys and their after-the-fact observations.
On the other hand, I’m not that inclined to agree with the article by Yolanda Young. Her idea, that the African American community is slowly becoming paranoid of white men and their intentions for our children, is far-fetched in my opinion. The black community has never been paranoid per se, only cognizant of the possible dangers that exist when confrontations between the races occur. My parents taught me and I, in turn, taught my children. We would be fool-hardy not to do so as it’s not paranoia, it’s survival, plain and simple.
Ms. Young likens the warnings we give to our offspring today as the same warnings given to blacks at the height of Jim Crow, when African Americans were being lynched almost on a daily basis and had to have a playbook on how to navigate in the white world. However, she characterizes today’s cautions to our children as hyperbole and calls them unnecessary. I beg to differ.
When I think of evil, I’m of the mind of Justice Scalia in his statement about pornography in that, “I know it when I see it”. I feel this way because truthfully, evil does exist and I have seen it. Whether it’s the smug, assured and confident evil depicted by the Michael Dunn’s of the world, individuals who do their dirt willingly and readily, under the assumption that every man will appreciate their “right” to do so or whether it’s the tentative, fearful evil shown by the George Zimmerman’s who, having done their dastardly deeds, are now fearful that they may have bitten off more than they can chew yet still throw their selves on the mercy of hopeful, public sentiment.
Both are equally despicable and both would be equally guilty in a court of law, in my mind. We as a country have to be prepared for the individuals that Mr. O’Mara warns us about; those who are looking for a reason to pull a gun on a lone, unarmed black man. Furthermore, as long as the courts are reluctant to go the extra mile with their jurisprudence to ensure that all facets of the defendants’ actions, as well as his or her state of mind, are vetted, then it’s only prudent that black parents continue to instruct their children into the dangers that could befall them.
When all is said and done and if given the opportunity, I would ask Ms. Young two questions. First, do you have any children? And if she answered in the affirmative, I’d then ask her, “What do you tell them?